
Get more details about this project
What you need
1 pool noodle (yellow for the classic pencil look, but go wild! or spray paint)
Brown craft paper or cardstock (for the tip)
Silver duct tape (for the metal band)
Pink craft foam or sponge (for the eraser)
Black sharpie or craft paint (optional, for #2 pencil details)
Utility knife or serrated bread knife
Hot glue gun or strong craft glue
Instructions
Step 1: Shape the Tip
Use a serrated knife to gently carve one end of the pool noodle into a blunt point. Think colored pencil—not too sharp, just angled. Don’t worry if it’s not perfect; imperfections add charm! You can create the tip using cardboard also. I like to do both as the foam noodle under the cardboard point adds stability to the pencil tip.

For the pencil tip use light brown kraft paper to create the tee pee point by cutting a circle and wrapping it.
Step 2: Add the Pencil Lead
Cut a small triangle of brown cardstock or construction paper and glue it to the pointed tip. This becomes your pencil “lead.” You can also color the tip with brown or black paint for extra definition.
Step 3: Wrap the Metal Band
Wrap 2–3 inches of silver duct tape around the opposite (flat) end of the noodle to mimic the metal ferrule that holds the eraser.
Step 4: Make the Eraser
Cut a chunk of pink foam or sponge to size and glue it to the silver end. It should look like a classic rubber eraser. Press firmly to secure!
Step 5 (Optional): Personalize It
Use a black Sharpie to add a faux #2 label, doodles, or even a student’s name if you’re using these as classroom door props.
Crafty Tips:
- Want a rainbow set? Use colored noodles for funky pencil styles!
- Use these as classroom props, photo booth accessories, or even to label reading corners (“Sharpen Your Mind” anyone?)
- Swap pink for red to make “colored pencils” for themed parties.
Why We Love This Craft
This pool noodle pencil tutorial is not only affordable, but endlessly customizable. It’s perfect for teacher appreciation gifts, first day of school photos, preschool décor, or just some light-hearted DIY fun with your kiddos. And let’s be honest—oversized crafts just bring oversized smiles.


















What do you think of this project? Let us know!